Wednesday, March 17, 2010
An Analysis of Nicky Beer's "The Word"
In the case of Nicky Beer’s “The Word”, the impact of one simple word on a young woman’s life has drastic repercussions on the world around her. In “The Word”, Nicky Beer’s short story that was first featured in the summer of 2008 on the website NarrativeMagazine.com, tells the story of a loving relationship that a young woman has with a seemingly ordinary word. The word first came to her attention on an average day while she was reading, but from that brief introduction, “[…] she continued to think about it—idly at first, then with increasing attention.” She began to imagine her own visual interpretations of the word and what it might look like, each one more unique than the last. The more she thought about it, the more the word seemed to affect her life for the better, eventually leading her to acknowledge to herself that “[…] she and the word were made for each other.”
At the height of “The Word”, the woman revisited the book where she first discovered the word and to much to her surprise, the word came right off of the page onto her fingertip. She then decided to make the word her own, protecting it in “[…] a small embroidered bag on a string around her neck when she went out.” The word became her property, and from then on the meaning of the word had been changed forever. Little did the woman know that by taking the word and making it her own, she removed it from the vocabulary of society itself, the repercussions of which were felt by politicians and prisoners alike, and though “Some of these adjustments were gradual and some instantaneous,” they all caused enough damage to the world that the woman slowly realize that because of her, the meaning of the word had changed not only for the rest of the world but for herself as well. She then ended her loving relationship with the word and set it free, never to be spoken or written by society ever again.
After reading “The Word”, I began to think of how much the story reminded me of nothing I’ve ever read or seen, as Beer combined the elements of many different stories and threw them into a big jumble of descriptive diction and bizarre imagery that makes up “The Word”. The possessive attitude the woman assumes over the word makes me think of people with OCD and their obsession with maintaining patterns in their lives, while the strange imagery Beer uses to describe the woman’s affection for the word reminds me of the strange drawings of Terry Gilliam in the Monty Python series.
Overall I enjoyed the story, though it was one of the stranger pieces of literature I have ever read.
-GV
Style of text in Superhero
First, I would like to discuss Reese's use of lists as styles. Below is an example of a list used in Superhero where Cassandra questions the existence of god.
" Questions about Belief
1. What kind of a God ruled by expecting everyone to believe in him based on an old book? Purely logically speaking, wouldn’t it have made more sense for him to give some sign of his existence every few years or so?
2. Old Testament God bragged so much. God insecure?
3. Why had so many of the saints been epileptic? What if all of their visions = delirium?
4. Who had ever moved a physical mountain with faith alone?
5. No parent worth the name would assign his or her child to continual torment, no matter the transgression. If God loved us, wouldn’t he want heaven for everyone regardless?
6. Limbo?
7. Darwin?"
From this list we get a whole different feel for what Cassandra is thinking. Imagine that Cassandra had listed these reasons off, but did so in a paragraph long rant. The style would command an entirely different feel. What I extract from the list is that Cassandra is an organized thinker, and is trying desperately to rationalize something that is very esoteric. In addition, as the list gets longer we can feel her frustration grow, and as a result her points get shorter. Reese uses this style on purpose in order to present Cassandra 's internal conflict between religious upbringing and intellectual style.
Second, I would like to discuss Reese's choice to develop Cassandra's relationship with Phil through the use of e-mails.
"To: philip.healey@yale.edu
Subject: Good luck at your game!
Dear Phil,
Wanted to write to tell you how wonderful you are, in case I hadn’t made that clear, and, you know, even if I had. I like the curve of your back, especially where it thickens, lower down. I like to look at you when you sleep. Late, nights, as the moon washes over us, I’ll study your face, wishing I knew how to draw. Sometimes you’ll have a flush across your face, as though you’ve just come in from the cold. I like to go to sleep tangled in your arms and your legs. I like when I wake up to find that your hand is cupped around my breast.
I like your voice, especially the way it resounds in your chest when I’m lying on you. I like when my cell phone rings and I look at it before picking up and it says your name. I love the way you hold me when I’m feeling down. I love the way you hold me when I’m feeling up. I love to say your name. I love the way you say my name.
I heard a joke once about an old WASP guy who says to his friend, “I’m so very much in love with my wife, it’s all I can do not to tell her!” I didn’t want to be like the old WASP guy. Is this a love letter? If so, it’s the first one I’ve ever written. Good luck against Dartmouth, and I can’t wait to see you when you get back tomorrow.
Love, Cassandra "
What I get from this style of writing, is it gives depth to the intensity and ridiculousness of their relationship. It feels romantic because it has the style of a chivalrous love letter, but it is held through an e-mail whose heading sits blaring at the top of the message. When I read this passage I imagined Cassandra typing this revealing, emotional, and carefully reviewed message, only to have it be delivered to Phil to the tune of a 'ping' or a 'you got mail' struck me as slightly ridiculous. In contrast to this perspective, it sets this couple apart from other couples. How many can honestly say that they have written a love letter to their love interest outside of a holiday card? At any rate, you can take away from it what you like, but I believe that the author's choice to include an actual letter is a fascinating choice.
Thirdly, I would like to discuss Reese's use of the phone dialogue. Although phone communication is brought up many times in the text. We only hear actual dialog when Cassandra is speaking with her mother.
"Finally Cassandra herself picked up the phone, and her mother asked why everyone was so confused. Cassandra laughed and explained that, for whatever reason, everyone had started calling her Cassandra. She asked, 'It is a pretty name, though, don’t you think, Mother?'
Her mother said, 'It is a nice enough name, but, sweetie, you know there really aren’t any saints named Cassandra.'
She laughed again, 'It’s just a nickname, Mother.'"
We can almost see Cassandra nonchalantly twirling her hair with the phone on her shoulder. She gives off the impression that she doesn't care at all what her mother is saying, and is merely calling as a courtesy. The image of Cassandra on the phone with her mother changes the way we feel about this conversation. If it were held in person it might have a distinctly different feel. One final note, is that despite the fact that Cassandra wishes to appear uncaring and independent of her mother, she actually desperately needs her support, and really relies upon these conversations with her mother. We see this in her closing paragraph after Cassandra gets her abortion. She admits her desire to tell her mother everything about her life, but is so determined to maintain her uncaring face, that she is unable to do so. This gives us more depth as to how Cassandra truly feels.
Reese repeats the use of love e-mails, and phone dialogue with the mother consistently to developed these images. It is because of this repetition of style that we can pick up on what Reese is actually trying to say about her characters. Through lists we see Cassandra's intelligence, through e-mails we see Cassandra's passion, and through the phone dialogue we see Cassandra's rebelliousness.
TY
Thursday, March 4, 2010
"The Word" by Nicky Beer
This passion conveyed in “The Word” reminds me of Matilda’s obsession in Mister Pip by Lloyd Jones. Throughout the story of Mister Pip, a teacher named Mr. Watts reads a story about a boy named Pip in Great Expectations written by Charles Dickens, to many students and one in particular, Matilda. Similar to the obsession over the word, Matilda finds herself completely infatuated over this boy named Pip as if it is an escape from her chaotic lifestyle. For example, in Mister Pip, Matilda remarks, “Well no, Pip wasn’t a relative, I explained, but I felt closer to him than the names of those strangers she made me write in the sand” (76).
Throughout the short story- “The Word,” Beer writes with detailed and abstract imagination. As depicted in the story, she possesses constant thoughts of the word that allow her to daydream and live her life surrounding this so-called “word.” A significant line in “The Word” is as follows, “She began to see the word, or traces of it, wherever she went: in the blackened gum embedded in the sidewalk, in the fissures of tree trunks, in the beads of oil shivering on the skin of a puddle.”
This notion of the word as an idea is a reminiscent of my tennis team and its singular, yet multi dimensional focus on my life. For the mere word of team constitutes a mass of visuals and emotions revolving around my team life from breathing, sweating, listening, speaking, Gatorade slurping, eating, and cheering on my teammates. Team then transcends to the value of deep, trusted, and valuable friendships similar to that of the valued “word.”
Another notion for believing that the word is deeper than one singular word is to observe the purest thought association of a child. Taking the word and making it an idea occurred today with my cousin Kate. As a two and one half year old who values security, comfort and a desired balance in life, walks into STARBUCKS with me, and utters without prompting, “Mommy likes STARBUCKS, Daddy likes Jack-In-The-Box, I’m ok.” The green word STARBUCKS provoked a reaction that streamed through her mind and landed in the right place. Kate’s thoughts are quite similar to those that the author possesses in the idea of “The Word”. She finds herself imagining the word in various instances as if it is shaping her life and resting, in this case, quite peacefully.
C.S.
Wednesday, March 3, 2010
"The Word" by Nicky Beer
“She began to imagine what the word would look like if it were seven inches high and made of green glass, and then how a women’s rugby team might go about spelling it with their bodies across a newly mown field. That night she stayed awake for many hours, convinced that the lightning bug on the ceiling was signaling the word in Morse code, and when she finally did fall asleep, she dreamed of steaming the word and tossing it in a light lemon butter sauce before eating it with a side of roasted asparagus. She began to see the word, or traces of it, wherever she went: in the blackened gum embedded in the sidewalk, in the fissures of tree trunks, in the beads of oil shivering on the skin of a puddle” (Beer).
These images she paints would have no effect on the reader unless, of course, they are placed back into the context of the story. Through her marvelous imagery, Beer allows the reader to imagine their own words in place of the personified word. Moreover, Beer’s unique and playful choice of words transforms the images and gives it an endearing quality by using simple and literal definitions. This obsession Beer’s main character has only mimics the real obsession humans have with written language. Beer’s use of language merely scratches at the surface of the ability of writers to express ideas creatively. However, Beer’s character loses interest in the word because the word had too much baggage, expressing human’s fickle and volatile attitude toward all things in life, especially those that are important to the individual. Once the word held too much meaning and strayed from what it originally meant to the main character, she no longer wanted to associate herself with the word. People, like Beer’s main character, stray from those who have changed. These people, hoping that the individuals they associated with remain the same, will no longer remain with the people have strayed from who they used to be.
-OA
"The Word"
So is the case in “The Word,” a short story by Nicky Beers featured on NarrativeMagazine.com in the summer of 2008. This story follows the relationship between a woman and a word. The meeting occurred on an average day leisurely reading, but at the first sight of this word, the woman was hooked, “thinking about it long after she had turned the page.” The infatuation with this word continues to grow as she thinks about it day and night, allowing its power to brightened up her day. The attraction reaches a climax so high that the woman decides to hold complete ownership of the word. “She kept it in her pocket […] and carried it in a small embroidered bag on a string around her neck.” The bond is so strong and inseparable that “she eventually had it tattooed discreetly on the right side of her pelvis.” So with that move, the word had a permanent place on the woman’s body and in her life.
The ripple effect from the removal of the word from society is unraveled with “the word [being] blurred or blacked out in manuscripts.” People encountering the word are faced with a blank space and soon it’s as if the word no longer existed. Time passes and the woman soon realizes the flaws of the word and she comes to the conclusion that “the meaning of the word had changed.” Thus end of the relationship between the woman and the word and the two part ways.
Lesson learned from this story: never obsess over anything for it will inevitably lose its impact and lack all meaning. Applying specifically to writers, simply don’t overuse just one word in your writings because the overly excessive use will cause it to lose its meaning and purpose.
Upon finishing reading this story, I immediately likened this story to the movie “All About Steve.” Now I know it’s embarrassing admitting that I watched this movie, which isn’t all that good, but I’m a big fan of Sandra Bullock so why not give it a try. What struck so similar between the two is the obsession that the woman has to the word and the obsession Sandra Bullock has to Bradley Cooper’s character in the movie. Bullock becomes so obsessed that she stalks Cooper and follows him as he travels for work and she never lets him out of her sight. In the end, as she gets to know him better and sees that he isn’t as good as she thought, the attraction dies down and she moves on with her life.
What I found to be the most interesting part about “The Word” is the feeling that you are left with at the end of the story. The word that the woman obsesses over remains completely unknown and mysterious to the reader throughout the whole story, which forces you to contemplate what word would have that much power over you. Definitely read “The Word” and figure out what your word is. My word is copacetic, what’s yours?
--
LT
Faces of a Tetrahedron
This analogy of a tetrahedron strongly resembles Franz Kafka’s art. Kafka embodies four distinct personas in every creation. These personas become the different faces of Kafka’s personality; therefore, become the faces of the tetrahedron. Kafka often attempts to hide certain personality traits in his work yet they all are visible in every one of his artistic expressions. He attempts to keep the characteristics that negatively influence him latent in his writings; ironically, these often are the most noticeable because they are the most relatable. Throughout life, Kafka’s true identity was forced to remain a secret; this causes his struggle to find a place in society. He attempts to release the frustration of an unborn identity through his writings. This led to the dissatisfactory image of himself shown through “A Hunger Artist.” The Hunger Artist, rather Kafka, wishes for people to want to be close to him. Kafka yearns for the scene of compassion between two beings which he never had. However, in the story, as the Hunger Artist gains fame, the more people of society start to examine his every move; thus becomes dissatisfied with his performance. This is a reflection of Kafka in relation to his writings. Towards death, Kafka states that he wants all of his works to be burned; yet ironically, he did not want to burn them himself. This could have initiated his decision in naming this piece of literature “A Hunger Artist” instead of “The Hunger Artist.” He might have believed that there just might be another human being that feels the same way he did insisting of using “A”, to imply one of many. When the Hunger Artist starts to fade away in the eyes of society and the well fed people move quickly on to the other animals this closely mirrors Kafka left unnoticed at the edge of his death yet free from the confinement of society. The two characteristics that affect Kafka negatively are imprisonment and intimidation, however, there is an equal amount of positive—art and faith. It is with these four qualities that allow Kafka to be compatible to his readers on multiple levels. The faces of the tetrahedron are found in everyone’s life.
It is with this tetrahedron that Kafka becomes of relevance in our lives as readers and we gain relevance to society. When we encounter Kafka’s art we are forced to see our embodiment of different personas that all function in unity, as they create a solid tetrahedron. If artist can feel comfortable producing art that is not perfect they will inspire others to not be controlled by the fear of judgment. Kafka gives inspiration to create art without judgment to his audience through a genuine connection of understanding that can only be obtained through art.
“A Hunger Artist” can be found:
Kafka, Franz. “A Hunger Artist.” The Story and Its Writer. Ann Charters. Boston, MA: Bedford/ St. Martin’s, 2007. 680-687.
By Kara Scofield
Mona Lisa M.K.
Mona Lisa
"The Word"
“When she finally put her book down, she continued to think about it—idly at first, then with increasing attention.”
Words and literature can take on many different meanings depending on one’s perspective. The girl in “The Word” grew to this word and idea, likewise, Matilda, from Lloyd Jones’ novel Mister Pip, becomes captured in the world Charles Dickens has created known as Great Expectations.
“At work she no longer shrugged or fidgeted or spoke hesitantly but expressed herself frankly, always looking people straight in the eye. “
The effects of the literature are obvious. The word takes over her life creating this new persona that comes through, noticeably different to those around her, just like Matilda. Before Mr. Watts introduced Great Expectations, Matilda was just like any other child within her village on Bougainville. What Great Expectations brought out of Matilda was maturity and a passion to understand the life of Pip.
For Matilda the story of Pip was one she could not forget. Even after her escape of Bougainville and her new life, she returned to the one thing she had left. For years she devoted herself to studying Great Expectations and the other works of Dickens and even traveled to see the history of the book. It was something she could come back to and instantly reconnect with. Similarly, the girl from “The Word” is able to return to where she first saw the word and re-enter that alternative world.
“She decided that she would go back to the page where she first noticed it. When she settled into her chair and opened up the book, it was as though the word had been waiting for her. She couldn’t help but smile with recognition, and unconsciously she raised her finger to trace the letter’s shape.”
In the end some things are just forgotten. People grow up and move on. This is the case with both Matilda and the girl with “the word”. The girl eventually sets her word free, letting it go. Matilda finds Pip as a figure of the past.
“Every one says the same thing of Dickens. They love his characters. Well, something has changed in me. As I have grown older I have fallen out of love with his characters. They are too loud; they are grotesque.” (Jones 253)
These two pieces of literature represent something that has come and gone. At one point in time, it was the center of focus, the utmost important. They are very much like a cherished item a young child holds onto. As they are young they hold on to it, but as they grow older, more mature, it is no longer a focal point of their life. SK
Word on The Word
“What she didn’t know, however, was that the moment she lifted the word from its place on the page, it became solely and utterly hers.” The character becomes consumed by this word and its meaning. She begins to change and act out a certain persona according to this word. Much like we try to act according to a character in movie who we thought was cool or inspiring, we change for a while to act like this idol.
Through her abstract portrayal of ,what I believe, is literature as a whole, the author touches on the point of what literature can do. Nicky Beer shows that literature and “word” can change people, the world, history, and conversation. If this short story was a film it would be Crash, just like this film, the Word begins with the reader confused but after reading, the reader can put the events together to better understand what it is that the author is trying to get across
The Word, I believe, touches on how we as readers become part of the story we read. We escape to that world and make it our own. Just as Matilda in Great Expectations escapes into the world of nineteenth century England, as an escape from her own distraught reality. We all become a part of what we are reading. The language that the author uses is what makes us attach to the characters and as a result, the story.
The one thing that stood out as a message was the way the main character becomes so entranced by the word, and the way she changes herself according to that. “After a few days of this, significant changes began to take place. At work she no longer shrugged or fidgeted or spoke hesitantly but expressed herself frankly, always looking people straight in the eye. She now had a glass of wine with lunch and spent much of the midafternoon humming to herself while she completed her tasks.” This happens to all of us, I believe, after seeing a movie or reading a novel. When I was a child and reading my first Harry Potter book I became so persistent that when I turned eleven I too would receive a letter from Hogwarts. The literature became a part of me, I wanted to be exactly like Harry. The same thing happens after we watch movies, afterwards we want to be like that main character. We try so hard to be the idol.
The end part of the short story confused me however. I don’t quite get why it is the main character bores of the familiar word. I feel that what we read becomes a part of us. I don’t think it all the sudden just vanishes. We might grow tired of the story but, I don’t think it loses its meaning. I think the ending is highlighting on the point that when we first read something, it becomes completely ours. We hold on to that story and it is almost as if the we are the only ones in the world thinking of it. After a stretch of time it returns into the hands of everyone else.
JL
"Superhero" and "The Word"
Similarly, Beer, author of The Diminishing House, depicts the obsession a woman finds with a single word. She begins to visualize the word around her, using it as often as possible in conversations and letters, and, in many ways, claiming its identity. The confidence growth that comes along with the word results in others saying that she must be in love or having sex. The woman’s obsession reaches a high when she begins to believe that “she and the word were made for each other.” Although she eventually relinquishes the word’s identity, the woman’s obsession with the simple word sanctifies it beyond its natural realm resulting in its inability to exist to any other person.
At first glance Beer’s “The Word” has almost no relation to Kwon’s “Superhero,” but I believe that the main characters are, in fact, the same. Both have been able to view a single person, or in the woman’s case, a single word in an idealistic manner, seeing no faults and as a result having the ability to fully devote attention to it. The woman physical attachment to the word, by wearing it around her neck, showed her constant need to know that the word is there at all times, in the same way that “Cassandra loved his constancy,” in her mind he was dependable because he was also always around in some way. Both characters maintain a deep connection to their obsession and in no way see it as absurd, although those around them to not seem to understand the interest. Both characters also undergo a simple change as a result of their obsession. The woman finds that she is not in love with her word, although at one time she believed she was. Cassandra also finds that she is willing to disappoint her family, in small ways, to keep Phil near her. Although both characters are very different, they are in many ways very similar.
JS
"Superhero"
“Superhero” is a story about a girl from a religious family, so religious that her parents named her Christina after Saint Christina. Christina goes to college and insists on being called Cassandra, dropping her family’s strong belief in God. She would ask herself things like “Why indeed had God created pain?” and asked God for a sign to terminate her doubtfulness in faith. Then, one day, she meets a boy named Phil. She loved him. “He called every day without fail, often several times a day, and the sense of loving him was as steady as the sun on a spring day.” This love made her happy. This love gave her life a little bit of color beyond the gray. Eventually she finds out she is pregnant. She was scared, losing faith in God and losing enough faith in her relationship with Phil to lie to him and tell him that she isn’t pregnant. “…she waited two hours in a great blanketing silence, the world had changed into a cosmos so large and unfriendly, and she had felt so cold, that she wrapped herself in her bed for the rest of the day.” She couldn’t tell her mother about the abortion either. She needed love then; someone to go to for support. She denied that option and couldn’t follow her heart. “…she went to her common room window and stood and looked out at the campus alight with April, and she looked at the cold, clear sky, and she thought of what it might be like to fly like a superhero, to fly like a saint.” She wanted to be somebody, instead of just an ordinary girl living in a world of despair. Her life went back to being gray, lost and lonely.
Faith doesn’t need to come in the form of religion. It can come in the form of love. Love is the most powerful thing and the heart is its most powerful tool. You should always listen to your heart and have faith in your actions. If you think about it, the world is a very dull, gray world unless you add a bit of color to it. Express your colors, good or bad. Have faith that there is help. Cry and turn your life blue. A lot more than sadness comes from the color blue, like the beautiful ocean. Red can represent anger, or love. On the other hand, gray will always be gray. “Superhero” portrays life comparable to the Mona Lisa or a bland dish with missing spices. Like adding color to a painting or adding salt to your eggs, you should add to your life. Add love. Add faith. And don’t ever subtract these wonderful things you attain.
Written by Reese Kwon, “Superhero” can be found at narrativemagazine.com. The story coveys messages worth thinking about and has points that ought to be made. Reese Kwon is a brilliant writer for using such an unpleasant, but realistic story to spark thoughts about life. Kwon can really get the reader to think through her stories, giving meaning to every word, and she is definitely a strong candidate for an author to look in to.
-NC
"Superhero" or Saint
“Philosophy has its place. But in the end, one chooses Homer over Plato, Goethe over Kant, Stevens over Wittgenstein” says her precious college professor Henry Wheelwright. In the end she has to choose one over the other: Cassandra over Christina or will it be saint over superhero? Or religion over philosophy? Although Cassandra gave up her Catholic faith, she finds herself returning to it by reciting prayers and passages. And no matter the extent of her transformation, she remembers her religion and her old self as Christina.
I find Kwon’s same tone and use of frothy language in Nicky Beer’s “The Word” found at narrativemagazine.com. Beer’s tells the story of a woman who stumbles upon a word (left unknown, allowing the reader to place their own word instead) and makes it a part of her: “she dreamed of steaming the word and tossing it in a light lemon butter sauce before eating it with a side of roasted asparagus. She began to see the word, or traces of it, wherever she went: in the blackened gum embedded in the sidewalk, in the fissures of tree trunks, in the beads of oil shivering on the skin of a puddle.” Beer plays with imagery and the senses and when you read the story out loud your mouth will water with every word and metaphor.
“The Word” and “Superhero” show the power of the voice (or individual words) and its simple influence over people and the world. This short story would be a famous sculpture in the Louvre like the Greek goddess Winged Victory of Samothrace. It would be a symbol of beauty, immortality, and passion but at the same time broken, lost, and unable to fly away. The last line of “Superhero” reads; “she thought of what it might be like to fly like a superhero, to fly like a saint.” Like a statue, painting, poem, or story; literature is a voice, an outlet, a means of escape, and a connection to our reality, as seen in the stories of Kwon and Beer. I challenge you to read this story and, like Cassandra, find your place in the wonderment and diversification as an intellectual. KW
" Superhero"
“ Superhero” By Reese Okyong Kwon, found on www.narrativemagazine.com, is the perfect example of the never-ending conflict between religion and philosophy. Christina, a young girl just about to start college has given up religion. She decides to go by Cassandra instead of Christina. As the story progresses we see the “ Cassandra’s” internal conflict, torn by her constant need for logic, for example her questions about belief and her difficulty totally giving up religion. The fact every time she is drunk she brings up religion shows that it is still a part of her that she has a hard time giving up and that she is somewhat reluctant to. Furthermore there is the fact that she felt a very strong sense of guilt not only when a guy wanted to go further with her while they were hooking up, but also after she had her abortion. In my opinion, this internal conflict has made “Cassandra” unable to deal with reality, because she doesn’t know which reality to turn to. The fact that she changes her name, the fact that she lies to her boyfriend about her abortion, the fact that she lies to her mother about having changed her name shows her incapability to deal with reality and could also show some self-loathing. Because she loathes herself, she feels the need to create an alternate identity, one of a girl who live in a world of sex, philosophy and complete logic. She turns herself into the girl she wishes she could be, to erase the person that she is. This creation of an alternate identity is in direct correlation to her boyfriend Phillip. Phillip is everything she wishes she could be and is very compatible with the person she pretends to be. He’s confident about his convictions, he thinks solely in terms of logic and philosophy.
This short story is a lot like another one that she wrote called “ Christine Jiyoung Yi Ingram”. There are a lot of themes that can be found in both stories. There is the theme of lying. The creation of a new identity. Both main characters in both stories cannot seem to be able to deal with reality. In “ Christine Jiyoung Yi Ingra,” Christine, cannot deal with the death of her father. She also creates an alternate identity to appeal to a person that she wants to have a romantic relationship with. She transforms herself into the person she wishes she could be to appeal to him. In “ Superhero”, “ Cassandra” creates a sort of distance between her and her family because she tries to separate herself from religion. In the same way Christine separated herself from her father, she hadn’t spoke to him for a year and a half.
Ultimately, “ Superhero” shows the conflict between philosophy and religion in a person’s mind and also shows the strength of Cassandra’s religious education because despite her thirst for logic, she still has a hard time completely giving up her religious education and letting philosophy completely take over her beliefs.
L.B
"The Dead" by James Joyce
“The snow doesn't give a soft white damn whom it touches.” ~E.E. Cummings
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Can We Be Superheroes? "Superhero" by Reese Okyong Kwon
Phil laughed, a good, healthy laugh. “Thanks for letting me know. I’ll keep it in mind.”
“And bother rhymes with slaughter. Well, not really...” -“Superhero”
An above dialogue from a short story called “Superhero”, I’ve just read a few weeks ago from Narrative Magazine.com. I can’t say its a work that I’ve come to like very much but it presented some provoking thoughts. The author Reese Okyong Kwon was presented the Million Writers Award for Notable Story of 2008 for this piece. The work introduces a Yale freshman named Christina who sheds her Catholic religious beliefs and changes her given name to Cassandra. Throughout her freshman year, she grows distant from her concerned mother and dives deep into a life filled with sex and impulsive actions. In the end, “Cassandra” makes an attempt to steer her life back in control by aborting a two and a half month old fetus but instead leaves the operation in confusion and despair. As an adopted American who could have been aborted by her mother in college, I feel that “Cassandra” was incorrect to observe abortion and keeping the child as the only two options available to her. There are adults out there looking to start their families but are unable to reproduce themselves. Those types of people are out there, opening their arms to children without homes.
However, I can sympathize with her struggle to fit in at college, as seen in the act of her shedding the life she was brought up into. Reading Superhero brought back memories of a book I read in 6th grade called Blister by Susan Shreve. Like “Cassandra,” the young fifth grader named Alyssa Reed changes her attitude and name to “Blister” in order to cope with a stillborn sister, a sudden move, and a parental divorce. She chooses to reinvent herself as an over-confident, almost over-the-top girl dressed in clothes stolen from a mystery suitcase in her father’s apartment. “Blister” successfully manages to turn many heads similar to “Cassandra’s” entrance to college. Yet all of these actions that “Blister” chooses to make are done as an attempt to fit in at her new school. She makes these drastic changes to herself knowing that the meek and nice girls do not get far in her school’s social system. “Cassandra” makes her own changes at college after feeling pressured to agree with her boyfriend Phil about religion being merely a crutch for people to support themselves.
“Cassandra’s” college life starts out well but progresses into a mess of epic proportions. Before she knows it, she has cornered herself into a conflicted battle with what was right and what was wrong. Her transition throughout college reminded me of Japanese ramune candy. Ramune is a Japanese soda that is lightly sweetened with touches of fruit flavor. The candy itself starts out sweet in your mouth then transitions into a sour taste. Soon after, the candy center fizzes and bubbles energetically in your mouth, wearing down gradually into nothing.
If this type of short story of drama and deception is your kind of read, dive in, take a look, and be prepared to emerge with a different look on life.
"Superhero" by Reese Kwon
The first thing we learn about this girl is that she renounced her faith a couple of months before college, and from there, her mind revolved around religious memories, philosophical references, intellectual thoughts, and Philip Healey. In choosing between the conflicts of emotions, intelligence, and religion, I believe she substitutes God’s place in her heart with Philip; Christina, or Cassandra, needs a crutch, someone to depend on, and that is her main priority throughout the story.
When she didn’t have her god, she relied on fantasy and dreams to get her though the day. Christina did not like “…to be alone and without prayer, with no one to talk to at night,” and her imagination began to run wild with the idea of being immortal, whether superhuman or vampire (2, Kwon). Once she entered the college life, Christina felt more at ease and depended less on fantasy and more on academic studies. When Philip arrived in her life, all crutches disappeared, and her happiness began to solely rely on him. I find it ironic that Philip told her religion wasn’t for her because she isn’t “the type to need a crutch” (4, Kwon), when all she looks for is someone to count on to make her happy and needed. Philip was dependable, and from what she says, Philip “defines dependable” (7, Kwon). Her love for him was based on the fact that he was there for her when she needed it versus the fact that God had never given her a sign of his existence during her high school years.
In Lloyd Jones's novel Mister Pip, Matilda similarly chooses academics over religion for something to rely on. Pip from Great Expectations was something she could confide and feel more strongly about than God or the Bible that her mother always presented to her. Matilda wanted to speak to Pip about her mother and her life because she found a friend in him; she knew, eventually, that she has to choose between her mother and Pip (46, Jones).
MR
In the short story Superhero, author Reese Kwon frequently presents the idea of cultural values remaining with a person throughout their lifetime. Although Christina decides to abandon Roman Catholicism in just the beginning of the story, the values and traditions embedded in the religion remain in her character throughout Superhero, despite her inevitable rebellious persona. A parallel idea is presented in Mister Pip by Lloyd Jones, when Matilda escapes Bougainville, yet still demonstrates the cultural values presented to her through the character of Pip in Great Expectations back on the island. Both authors are greatly admired and well-respected professionals honored with numerous accolades, among which include the Wallace Prize from Yale for Kwon and a short listing for the Man Booker Prize for Jones.
In the opening paragraph of Superhero, Kwon immediately demonstrates that Christina has recently abandoned her religion, claiming that “it was only a few months after Christina renounced God that she went off to college,” (Kwon 1). Shortly after, Christina begins to get heavily intoxicated on a frequent basis, and, when drunk, she would “lie in her bed wrapped in her comforter reciting biblical scraps she remembered…she would walk toward her desk and retrieve the rosary beads that she kept tucked behind the papers in the bottommost drawer, and, back in her bed, she would worry the rosary beads, her addiction, her contraband,” (Kwon 4). Although Christina has become an adult and decided to remove religion from her life, the cultural values embedded in her character since childhood inevitably remain with her.
An analogous idea is introduced in by Jones in Mister Pip through an allusion to Great Expectations by Charles Dickens. Even after Matilda leaves Bougainville, Pip remains active in her life. Despite the slaughter of Mr. Watts and Dolores, Matilda remains a strong and independent character, similar to Pip. In the conclusion of the novel, Matilda describes her interpretation of Mr. Dickens, claiming that she “never once saw him with a machete- his survival weapon was a story…Mr. Dickens had taught every one of us kids that our voice was special,” (Jones 256). When she escapes from the island to the real world, Matilda’s mind is still pondering on Great Expectations and how the work has been with her through all of the negative proceedings in her life- similar to the idea of religion for Christina. Although Mr. Watts is no longer reading it to her, the cultural ideas and values presented in Dickens’ novel remain with Matilda through the remaining chapters of the tale.
Lastly, the emphasis on the preservation of cultural values exemplified in the above novels is extremely relatable to my own personal life. Although I grew up in a Catholic home, I independently decided to become a Christian at the age of twelve when I was first enrolled in Grace Christian School. My mother was greatly disappointed at the fact that I had chosen to cease Roman Catholicism in our family. However, numerous practices, such as taking communion, remain with me and always will. There are a number of indentations in our memory which we cannot expunge.
In conclusion, various ideas and cultural values embedded into our character will remain with us throughout life, despite chronic rebellion and struggles. This idea is emphasized and reflected in Superhero by Reese Kwon and Mister Pip by Lloyd Jones through the characters of Christina and Matilda. Although they may hold incongruous values and opinions, both characters inevitably remain strong in their beliefs.
-KF